Szeto Wah, 1931-2011

A Hong Kong ‘democracy icon’ dies. From the Sing Tao group’s pro-Beijing/tycoon mouthpiece ‘Mary “saddened” Ma’ to the Hong Kong government, people who attacked what Szeto Wah fought for during his life now fall over themselves to mourn his parting. Even Communist Party-backed local propaganda sheet Wen Wei Po reports Chief Executive Donald Tsang’s official lament alongside the crappiest photo they can find.

As a respected and popular teachers’ union organizer who was also a Chinese scholar with deep grudges against the Japanese and the British, Szeto was exactly the sort of Hong Kong person whose endorsement Beijing needed in the years leading up to the 1997 handover. But he also had principles; he hailed the victims of the massacre in Beijing in 1989 as patriots and martyrs, and it is due to him more than any other individual that the city to this day hosts a mass-commemoration every year to remember June 4.

Thus it was that the CCP branded Szeto a subversive and barred him from setting foot over the border. (China’s continuation of the feudal practice of banishing its citizens from their own country – a hangover from the days when the people were the property of the emperor – will be highlighted yet again when the Immigration Department suspends Hong Kong’s official autonomy and kowtows, as it must, by barring exiled pro-democracy activists from entering the city for Szeto’s funeral at the end of the month.)

He wasn’t so much shunned by members of the self-described ‘elite’ that runs Hong Kong as the other way round. Some of our local oligarchs take a sort of guilty pleasure in enjoying good relations with opposition figures, especially if they cross paths in forums like the Legislative Council; there seems to be a dash of ‘radical chic’ about it, as well as a desire to play safe in case these people end up in charge one revolutionary day. Unlike his Democratic Party sidekick Martin Lee, Szeto wasn’t one to hobnob with the occasional tycoon.

He was the antithesis of the pompous, pretentious and under-qualified establishment that Beijing sided with – in effect – against the bulk of the city’s community. He happily wore shabby clothing, while they preen themselves in their grandiose uniform of cufflinks and silk ties. He read books, which is too hard, time-consuming and pointless for them to do. He prized ideas, while they crave money. For the aspiring golf-playing, Mercedes-driving set desperate for a medal or club membership he was a joke or an embarrassment, but for the more intellectual, less materialistic and numerous less well-connected he was an embodiment of Hong Kong values. A reminder, therefore, of what the shallow men who have had political and economic power handed to them on a plate are not. The fulsome praise from unlikely quarters on his death is not hypocrisy so much as shame.

This entry was posted in Blog. Bookmark the permalink.

12 Responses to Szeto Wah, 1931-2011

  1. Claw says:

    A man of integrity whose presence on the political scene in Hong Kong will be sorely missed. You fought the good fight well, Wah Suk, Rest in Peace

  2. Pat Caddell says:

    I’m not sure how many people realised that Szeto Wah was Henry Fok’s counterpart on the democratic side: he was the power behind the throne and no decisions were final until Uncle Wah gave the nod.

  3. Maugrim says:

    Szeto Wah stood for something, unlike some in politics who have no idea what it is they truly believe in, other than themselves.

  4. Phyllis Stein says:

    He was an inarticulate lazy individual with no real plan or vision for democratic development.

    Unable to form links with the trade unions or the masses in general

    A godsend for Peking.

    Left it to that silly vicar turned barrister Martin Lee to speak English and do most of the work.

    Death doesn’t give anyone automatic sainthood.

    Oops.

  5. mtcy says:

    Hard to believe the jibe is directed at the subject, rather than Hemlock, this time. However, Uncle Szeto is so widely admired in life and revered in death that, even from unlikely quarters, such mindless and heartless attack targeted at him cannot be more misplaced. Only someone from Mars, or quarters more unlikely than a distant planet, would regard our beloved Uncle Szeto as “unable to form links with…the masses”. A clear case of ignorance being a shame, rather than bliss.

  6. Phyllis Stein says:

    Politics is about money, blood and bullets.

    How many general strikes did Szeto organise? None.

    How many members did he have in his party? A few hundred.

    Good riddance to amateurs and affectionate uncles meddling in politics.

  7. mtcy says:

    No amount of number crunching is enough to disguise your ignorance of the importance and influence of our Uncle Wah, yes, not just Uncle Szeto, and definitely not your uncle.

    Show a little respect for the dead, if not for your own intelligence, if there is any.

  8. Phyllis Stein says:

    As regards respect for the dead, Szeto was an invalid and coffin dodger for about twenty years. He should have resigned but in the grand Chinese tradition he hung on and on instead of handing things over to the new generation.

    Stop corpse hugging and see facts in the face.

  9. mtcy says:

    Respect for the dead is perhaps too much to ask for the lower-ranking members of the animal kingdom. I rest my case.

  10. Phyllis Stein says:

    You’re just a cliche. Get out of your box. Sadly, Szeto can’t get out of his.

  11. the sixth wife of dickson poon says:

    SiPhylliss; you are committing the worst sin that a commentator can make: you are predictable and boring. Now go and watch yourself on XTube.

  12. Phyllis Stein says:

    Will do.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *