An SCMP op-ed offers a dash of ‘soft resistance’ on the subject of the Tai Po fire inquiry…
We also learned just how far our systems have fallen short in protecting Hongkongers’ lives and property. Even in the early days after the blaze, questions were raised over how the overlapping systems designed to avert disasters like the Wang Fuk Court inferno had failed.
…it has emerged that the fire alarm system did not function as it should have. While arrests have been made in the disaster’s aftermath, there is much more to uncover after widespread systemic failures that span construction, property management and government oversight came to light.
Beyond the substandard materials used and the disabled fire alarms, there are the regulatory loopholes and the long-standing issues of bid-rigging and industry corruption. These problems have long been known, but they keep returning to haunt us after being swept under the carpet.
…It was distressing to hear Secretary for the Civil Service Ingrid Yeung Ho Poi-yan say recently that the government might not make the commission’s investigation report fully public over privacy and confidentiality concerns. Surely redactions, if done properly, could address those concerns.
It’s hard to miss the corruption and other illegalities in Hong Kong’s construction/building maintenance sector these days. Missing rebar at the Anderson Road ‘starter homes’ project in Kwun Tong. More missing rebar at the One Stanley luxury villas. Shoddily installed lifts at Queen Mary Hospital. Failure to install fire-safe elevator door frames in no fewer than 338 buildings.
Maybe we need a well-resourced muck-raking newspaper, or some outspoken democratically elected lawmakers, or a free civil society in which residents can organize and protest.
Samuel Chu in LARB on his father – a veteran of Operation Yellowbird and the Umbrella Movement – and his own experiences of Hong Kong’s long tradition of protest…
Exactly a month earlier, on June 30, I had stayed up late waiting for the text of Hong Kong’s new national security law to appear online. The law had been drafted in Beijing in secret. No one in Hong Kong—not legislators, lawyers, or the public—had seen it. It would be unveiled only after it had already gone into effect. This was Beijing’s answer to the mass protests that had erupted the previous summer over a proposed extradition bill that would have allowed Hong Kong residents to disappear into mainland China’s courts. The law allowed ordinary acts of speech, protest, association, and publication to be prosecuted as “secession,” “subversion,” “terrorism,” or “collusion with foreign organizations.”
Once it appeared, I texted my legal counsel: “How do you think this affects us?” “Well,” they replied, “if you keep reading to Article 38, I think they wrote this for you.” This particular article stated that these laws applied to anyone “outside the Region,” as well as a “person who is not a permanent resident.” They had essentially proclaimed planetary jurisdiction. I was admittedly flattered. Not many people have a law drafted for them personally. Is this what it feels like to be wanted?


“Maybe we need a well-resourced muck-raking newspaper”
Er… never heard of HK01? It broke all of those stories you mentioned plus dozens more most expats didn’t even know about. Oh, but the Japan/Taiwan diaspora call it “pro-Beijing HK01” so I guess you won’t read it… your loss!
PS LMAO lil’ soggy Bickett “you get in there and make the NSL about you”. Dickhead.
I’d surmise that they* don’t want a full & open independent inquiry not because they do not know what will be uncovered, but because they know what will
@Josué Wong
Bickett? What are you on about. Seems your database is glitching.
You can spin it any which way but HK01 is a famed pro-Beijing rag, owned by a businessman with investments in China, with a long history of pro-Beijing stance, outspoken anti-Taiwan independence stance, it even refrained from reporting on new Tian An Men massacre findings, among many other instances.
@Load Toad. This will follow the trajectory of the 2012 Lamma Ferrry disaster – 39 deaths and numerous serious injuries – investigations.
2013 Commission of Inquiry
2016 The two captains bear the brunt
Families agitate for justice for a decade
2026 Coroner’s Inquest ruled the deaths unlawful but no further charges laid.
HKT / HK Electric and the various parties who neglected to fulfill their duties and allowed a vessal that was not seaworthy to operate ….. NADA
Speaking of the Tai Po Fire tragedy, SCMP’s favourite commentator said “The city showed a sense of community we haven’t seen in a long time”.
Would “a long time” be … 7 years? 12 years…?
“a sense of community we haven’t seen in a long time”.
Yeah, for two days until the apparatchiks moved in and the sommunity was kicked out.